Apply Direct of use a recruiter

Apply Direct Or Use A Recruiter

When considering a career move you may often face a key decision: should they apply directly to law firms, or should you work with a recruiter? Each approach has its own benefits and drawbacks, and the right choice depends on your career goals, priorities, and circumstances. Sometimes, a firm may contact you directly, leaving you with a different kind of decision to make.

Below we look at the pros and cons of applying directly, using a recruiter, and responding to a firm that reaches out to you first.

Applying Directly to Law Firms

You can choose to apply directly to law firms, either by responding to job postings or proactively reaching out to firms you are interested in. This approach can be ideal for those who want full control over their job search, have a good understanding of the market, are only interested in a limited number of firms and prefer to manage the process themselves.

Pros of Applying Directly:

Full control over the process – you decide which firms to target, how to tailor your application, and how to present yourself in interviews.
Direct communication – by applying on your own, you avoid any potential miscommunication through an intermediary, ensuring your preferences and goals are clearly understood.
Greater flexibility in negotiations – some firms may have more room to negotiate salary and benefits when they do not have to pay a recruiter’s fee.
Building relationships with the firm – applying directly allows you to establish personal connections with hiring partners or decision-makers early in the process.
Demonstrates initiative – law firms often appreciate candidates who take the time to research and apply on their own, as it signals genuine interest.

Cons of Applying Directly

Time-consuming – managing applications, scheduling interviews, and following up with firms can be a lengthy process and a difficult one to manage if you are very busy.
Limited access to hidden opportunities – not all roles are publicly advertised. Many of the US firms in the London market do not advertise their roles and several of the bigger UK international firms advertise some, but not all of their roles. Whilst some firms are effectively always on the look out for great talent so welcome direct approaches at any time, others are not. If you might be interested in firms that only use recruiters to source their candidates, you might be missing out on opportunities.
No buffer for discretion – if you are considering multiple roles or need to approach certain issues sensitively, applying directly may make it harder. Having an individual that acts as a go between can enable you to manage or approach scenarios in a more effective way.
Lack of guidance in the process – a good experienced and knowledgeable recruiters can provide market insights, resume/interview coaching and help with salary negotiation at the end of the process.

Working with a Legal Recruiter

Legal recruiters act as intermediaries and brokers, they help match candidates with opportunities that align with their experience and career goals. Using a good recruiter can be very beneficial, particularly if you want access to a broader range of roles, and need / prefer professional support throughout the hiring process.

Pros of Using a Recruiter

Access to opportunities not advertised in the public domain – if you are interested in some of the bigger US firms that don't advertise roles, then the recruiters that work closely with these firms should be aware of the active roles. Many of the smaller City firms will also not advertise their roles choosing instead to work with their preferred recruiters.
Saves time and effort – a recruiter can handle the logistics of your job search, including applications, interview scheduling, and follow-ups. If you are very busy this can be a valuable benefit.
Market insights and expert guidance – an experienced and expert recruiter in the legal sector can provide valuable advice on where you fit best in the market and provide insights into the firms that are difficult to obtain elsewhere.
Negotiation support – although recruiters are paid by firms they are acting as a broker and so want to ensure that a deal gets done. They can play a valuable role in ensuring you receive a salary and benefits package that you are happy with.
Help managing multiple opportunities – If you are considering several roles, a recruiter can help coordinate the process and keep options open, so that you do not have to make decision or commit to a firm before you know the outcomes at other firms.

Cons of Using a Recruiter

Limited control over firm selection – Recruiters present opportunities based on client needs, which may not always align perfectly with your preferences.
Pressure to accept a role – while reputable recruiters focus on the right fit, some may encourage candidates to accept offers quickly to close a placement.
Not all firms use recruiters – some law firms prefer direct applicants and may not consider candidates presented through an external recruiter. It is not necessarily beneficial for recruiters to proactively share this information with you.
Potential salary considerations – since firms pay a recruiter’s fee for placement, some may be less flexible with salary negotiations compared to direct hires.
Asymmetry of information - if you are not very knowledgeable about your market, then you may only know what the recruiter tells you. If this is the case, it is likely you will only find out whether it was right or wrong after you have made a move by which point it is too late. Choosing the right recruiter can make a difference.

When a Law Firm Contacts You Directly

Sometimes, the decision is made for you - a law firm reaches out to you first, expressing interest in bringing you on board. While this can be flattering and may indicate strong demand for your skills, it’s important to assess the opportunity carefully before making a decision.

Pros of Responding to a Firm That Contacts You

They’re already interested in you – being sought out means your experience aligns with their needs, potentially giving you an advantage in the hiring process.
Less competition – since the firm reached out to you directly, you may be competing against fewer candidates compared to public job postings.
Negotiation leverage – because they initiated contact, you may have more room to negotiate salary, benefits, and other terms.
Faster process – firms that proactively contact candidates often have an immediate hiring need, which can speed up the hiring timeline.

Cons of Responding to a Firm That Contacts You

Limited ability to compare options – if you weren’t actively job searching, you may not know if this is the best opportunity available.
Potential lack of fit – just because they are interested in you doesn’t mean the role or firm culture aligns with your career goals.
Feeling pressured to consider the role – if the firm has connections to your professional network, you may feel obligated to engage in the process, even if you’re unsure about the opportunity.
Unknown hiring strategy – some firms cast a wide net, reaching out to multiple candidates before narrowing down their shortlist. There’s no guarantee you are their top choice.

How to Handle a Firm That Contacts You

If a law firm reaches out to you directly, take these steps before deciding:

Gather details – ask about the role, expectations, compensation, and firm culture.
Do your research – look into the firm’s reputation, recent news, and overall work environment.
Compare with other opportunities – even if you weren’t actively looking, consider speaking with recruiters or exploring other roles to ensure you’re making an informed decision. Use our job search feature to see what other options are available.
Assess your long-term goals – is this move right for your career, or are you just considering it because they reached out first?
Negotiate from a position of strength – since they approached you, use that leverage to secure favourable terms.

If a firm has reached out to you and you are not sure what to do, we can help. We offer consultancy services where we can provide you with an overview of the market, objective advice on the firm and access to research needed. If you progress and are made an offer we can act as an intermediary in the salary negotiations to help ensure you achieve the best possible salary. For more information on our consultancy services click on the link below.

How The Rackle Can Help You

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to whether you should apply directly to a law firm, work with a recruiter, or respond to a firm that contacts you. The best approach depends on your current situation, career aspirations, and how much support you want during the job search process.

Whichever option you choose, The Rackle provides some support and help to combat some of the cons of each approach.

If applying direct:

Use our job search function to discover roles that are being advertised by firms on their website. We update jobs every two weeks and we cover over 150 firms that advertise roles on their websites.
Use our practice area overview to get a full understanding of the different firm options available in your practice area.
Get the benefit of the objective market insights from an experienced recruiter and lawyer by booking a bespoke consultancy session.

If using a recruiter:

Use our recruiter search feature to discover all of the different recruiters in the market so that you can make a fully informed decision on who to work with.
Remove the asymmetry of information problem by using our practice area search feature. We provide enough information about each practice area that should help ensure that you can determine how good the advice or insights you are being given are.
Get a bespoke guide to recruiters and some specific suggestions based on the sort of firms and roles that you are looking for by booking a bespoke consultancy session with our experienced legal consultant who has 25 years experience in the market having worked as a lawyer, a recruiter and a head of resourcing at a top 20 international firm.

If approached directly by a firm:

Use our job search function to discover other roles available so you can compare opportunities.
Use our practice area overview to gain insights into options that should become available over the next 12 months
Get the benefit of the objective market insights on the firm, relevant market insights and access to an intermediary for you in any salary negotiations by booking a bespoke consultancy session.

Consultancy Services - Tell me more